Put down the sword, instead own the shield
Karolina Kurkova, Paris Fashion Week A/w’04. Jim Cochrane/Shutterstock
“Treat everyone with politeness, even those who are rude to you - not because they are nice, but because you are.”
Oh, this is a quote as good as sharp relish on a delectable plate of seasonal nibbles! I quite openly admit that when I first came across the above expression I thought how important a lesson it harbors for us all. If the entirety of humanity adhered to such a principle of etiquette (i.e. civility in the face of harshness), wouldn’t the problem of rudeness eventually and irrevocably diminish all together? This is just a mere thought that passes through my mind often, especially when an uncalled for quip lands on my lap at a dinner party. It’s a rather tall order though, isn’t it? To be respectful to those who are disrespectful to you? Especially in a social setting where one act of rudeness can seemingly change the atmosphere of a room; like the sudden on-set of heavy clouds, unkindness brings with it a gloom… and no plate of hors d'oeuvres, or satin purse can serve as cover for the social rainfall that can ensue.
In short, rude behavior cannot be prevented. But it can be deftly iced by countering it with unconditional politeness. Eventually, the improper behavior, or heightened vitriol, will impact their reputation and their social cache. Some call it karma; I refer to it as social logic.
This is not an academic, socio-anthropological essay (thankfully) so there’s no need to define what is ‘rude’ and what is ‘polite’ beyond this: the former means ‘offensively impolite’ and the latter translates to ‘being respectful of others’. In Volume 1 of Modern Manners (see here), this concept was explored with the relentless enthusiasm of a puppy bouncing through Alpine snow. Fear not, my feverish desire to put more pen to paper on this topic hasn’t waned one bit. (That’s a cue-up for Volume 3, by the way). The practical question remains - how does one navigate a brash act of rudeness in a social setting, without being baited into returning the brittle behavior with a rhetorical swipe back? It's not easy. But it is possible.
Backstage Gucci, Paris Fashion Week SS19. Gil-Gonzalez Backstage/ABACA/Shutterstock
Here’s what I’ve gleaned from many years working with egoists in fashion & media and living life waltzing through various societal echelons:
#1: The rude action or comment is directed towards you in front of others. The first step is to NOT immediately react. This takes self control (something that maturity and practice can muster up).
#2: Avoid grimacing or showing a sudden change in your facial expression. Go for a total poker face. This will create space and a suitable distance between their behavior and your own.
#3: If you are afforded a moment to think, instead of assuming the worst about the person’s intentions, swap negative thoughts for this - be intrigued. Why did they do that? Are they feeling insecure, etc? Try not to overthink it but do consider that there is a reason behind the action and it’s not necessarily related to you or others present.
#4: This pause will calm down your limbic brain and avoid a sudden plummet into reactive behavior. You can now respond with either a boundary, a diversion, or empathy. Your mode of operating in this instance depends on your ability to read the room, the situation, and the dynamic.
#5: Get creative with your response. For instance, when someone openly insulted my head-to-toe outfit as being “far too overdressed” for the occasion and proceeded to make spiky comments in my direction within a group setting, here’s what I did. I set a confident boundary by saying, “me and my dress feel very happy together.” This acknowledged the person's comment (because ignoring someone is rude) but declared a subtle boundary that I was not interested in petty trivialities or jousting. It disarmed them without harming them socially.
#6: Re-route back to civility: In the aforementioned example, I proceeded to serve up a genuine question to someone else in the group that redirected the conversation towards others. Elevate the dynamic! Take charge and command that the vibe be constructive. Do not exclude the person who took a social stab at you, simply keep your eye contact inclusive of all so as not to bait them back into conflict with you. It really does work and navigates you well away from unkind verbal table tennis. Anyway, there is no such thing as being overdressed; only being underdressed. Own it.
This is what team Deenathe1st deems to be ‘radically elegant’ behavior in the face of unkindness. You have an invisible shield, not a sword, for those who are ill-mannered. It can be tempting to fire back with arrows of wit but it takes so much more power to stop something in its tracks.
Final thought for Volume 2 of This Modern Manners Guide - please use your napkin. No couture gown or vintage ready-to-wear garment should be subjected to crumbs.
Written by Philippa Morgan
READ Volume 1 all over again to prime yourself for almost any situation. Until next time…