What’s the relationship between the gut and your brain? So many Qs.
Photo Credit: Courtesy of Marieva Malo
WHAT'S relationship between the gut and your brain? According to UCLA's Dr. Emeran Mayer, "The gut converses with the brain like no other organ. When people talk about going with their gut feelings on an important decision, what they’re referring to is an intuitive knowledge based on the close relationship between our emotions and the sensations and feelings in the gastrointestinal (GI) tract." I’m well known for trusting my gut in most, if not all, of my decisions but I’ve been actively paying closer attention to what that really means in my day-to-day life and how it affects all areas of my being.
So what exactly is the gut? “Your gut is your gastrointestinal system and includes your stomach, intestines, and colon. It digests and absorbs nutrients from food and excretes waste,” as defined by Better Health. The gut and the brain are closely linked through bidirectional signaling pathways that include nerves, hormones, and inflammatory molecules. “When you eat too much or have certain fatty foods, the changes in your gut can affect your mental state,” Dr. Mayer notes. “And when you feel butterflies or a rumbling in your stomach when nervous, or knots in your stomach when you’re angry, your mental state is affecting your gut.”
"Our gut feelings might reveal something fundamentally true about our bodies."
We all know the feeling of butterflies in our stomach, which can be inexplicable. Being in love, being excited, or feeling discomfort—these feelings can lift you up or let you down.
Recently, I had to make a decision about moving. I found an apartment I fell in love with, though it was practically impossible to get. Still, something in my gut was telling me it was meant to be mine. I had a “gut feeling”.
I understand that this is a classic philosophical dilemma and Descartes might appreciate this, but my gut feeling highlighted the dualism between mind and emotion. Long story short (and I mean very short for the sake of this piece), after almost four months of back and forth, and learning a lesson or two about patience, perseverance, and grit, I got the place. During this time, I was already contemplating this article and consciously chose to pay closer attention to how my brain was affecting my gut. A Harvard study states that the gut is sensitive to emotions such as anger, anxiety, sadness, and elation—these feelings can trigger symptoms in the gut. This proved to be true; during this period of uncertainty and stress, my appetite and food cravings fluctuated. When I thought I wouldn’t get the apartment, I was hungrier, and when I glimpsed hope, my appetite disappeared.
Another example: when I was standing in front of a perfect pair of Phoebe Philo shoes while searching for summer sandals, I knew they weren’t right for me—too high, not the right shape, though unique and perfect in their own way. I made the move, chose to ignore my gut feeling, and prioritized my fashion needs. As Ralph Lauren said, “Fashion is about something that comes from within you,” and at that moment, that pair belonged in my closet. You guessed it—I haven’t found the occasion to wear them, and they’re still sitting untouched in my closet. Am I happy I ignored my gut feeling? Yes. I’ll make exceptions for Philo; but typically, I follow Vivienne Westwood’s wise advice: “Buy less, choose well.”
Photo Credit: Courtesy of Marieva Malo
In my anatomical soul-searching, I discovered that gut feelings date back to the 17th century. According to the Wellcome Collection / According to Michael Walkden, the physician Jan Baptist van Helmont argued that "the stomach was far more than just a factory for processing food. It was, in fact, the seat of the mediator between the physical and the spiritual realms: the sensitive soul.” On the other hand, the French philosopher René Descartes, a contemporary of van Helmont, hypothesized that the soul operated on the body through the pineal gland, an organ no bigger than a grain of rice nestled at the center of the brain. Scholars and physicians like Descartes and the English physiologist Thomas Willis used increasingly detailed anatomical studies of the brain to argue that the operations of the soul took place entirely within the head.
In reality, we have more control over our gut feelings than we realize. The more you trust yourself, tune into your body, and learn to listen to the signals, the more gut feelings become a medical reality. Our gut feelings might reveal something fundamentally true about our bodies. More than a metaphor, I believe the phrase "trust your gut" refers to trusting yourself by following these feelings of intuition and staying true to oneself. So, while I may not attribute my acquisition of the apartment solely to my gut feeling, or my decision to buy those shoes to ignoring it, my gut feeling certainly played a significant role in both cases.
Now, is there a dichotomy where the healthier you are, the more you can trust your gut; or the more you trust your gut, the healthier you are? I’m not claiming that a healthy gut will lead you to better decisions, nor am I suggesting that ignoring your gut feeling is beneficial. However, neglecting your gut and its signals won’t lead you far. Why is gut health important? Because it breaks down the foods you eat and absorbs nutrients that support your body’s functions, including making decisions. So, at the end of the day, trust your gut—ideally, a healthy gut.
Written by Marieva Malo
Marieva Malo is a Contributing Editor at Deenathe1st. Marieva was born in America and raised in Mexico. She’s a former dancer, certified health coach, pilates instructor and founder of The Way, a platform dedicated to fitness and pilates. Through her platform she dedicates her lifestyle to wellness, integrating choreographic movement, a holistic approach to breathing exercise, and a unique sense of style. Marieva devotes herself to her one true passion: the body and all its dimensions from physical to cultural to its social impact.
READ more from Marieva Malo’s column here in Fashion Thoughts